Casey Key Fish House

mussels marinara

prince edward island mussels in homemade marinara sauce with garlic bread

mussels

prince edward island mussels sautéed in white wine and garlic, and with garlic bread

u-peel-u eat shrimp

fresh, chilled shrimp, served with fresh lemon and cocktail sauce

u-peel, garlic shrimp

served warm. sautéed in fresh garlic

buffalo shrimp

lightly fried, plump & juicy shrimp - they're the best! served with carrots, celery sticks, blue cheese / hot sauce on the side

buffalo wings

some like them hot! served with carrots and celery sticks, blue cheese / hot sauce on the side

calamari

baby calamari, lightly breaded and fried to perfection. served with home made marinara sauce

onion rings

freshly cut, sweet onion, deep fried to perfection

conch fritters

a blend of our special seasonings, fried to a golden brown. served with tartar sauce

crab cakes

two crab cakes homemade with blue crabmeat, chopped sweet red bell peppers and stuffing, seasoned to perfection and topped with thai chili glaze

smoked mahi fish dip

served with crackers

grouper sandwich

snapper sandwich

mahi sandwich

cod fish & chips

battered shrimp

crab cakes

char-grilled burger, 1/2 lb

black bean burger

chicken breast char-grilled sandwich

chicken fingers

beef dog, 1/4 lb

battered dog, 1/4lb deep fried beer batter

grouper, pan seared

with white wine and tropical fruit salsa

sesame crusted pan seared tuna

with ginger soy wasabi sauce over asian stir fried noodles

baked stuffed shrimp w/ crab meat

fresh grilled salmon

topped with cucumber dill sauce served with starch and sautéed fresh veggies

fresh grilled mahi-mahi

with shrimp, sun-dried tomato, artichoke and mushroom, served with starch and sautéed fresh veggies

seafood pasta

shrimp, scallops, grouper and mussels, with fresh basil, tomato sauce served over pasta

shrimp scampi

sautéed shrimp, garlic, in a white wine sauce served over pasta

mussels with pasta

your choice of white wine garlic or marinara sauce

diver scallops with citrus sauce

served with starch and sautéed fresh vegetables

almond snapper, pan seared

encrusted with almonds & topped with a lemon butter sauce. served with starch and sautéed fresh vegetables

new york strip-angus beef 14 oz

hand-cut, served with wild mushroom cabernet demi glaze, starch and sautéed fresh veggies

sautéed chicken breast

served with artichokes, mushrooms, sun-dried tomato, starch, and sautéed fresh veggies

fish and chips (1 piece)

hot dog and fries

grilled cheese with fries

chicken fingers with fries

pasta with butter or marinara sauce

soft drink w/ refill

coffee w/ refill

ice tea w/refill

juice

chicken

mahi

grouper or shrimp

your choice of blackened, grilled, fried

garlic bread 3 pieces

side fries

side of veggies

side of home made cole slaw

house spring mix

caesar salad

key lime pie

pie of the day

new england clam chowder

soup of the day

turtles' cosmo

absolute mandarin, cointreau, lime & a splash of cranberry

lemon drop

absolute citron, triple sec, lemon & simple syrup

key lime martini

vanilla key vodka, key lime juice, liq 43

classic jim beam manhattan

jim beam & sweet vermouth

turtles organic "skinny" margarita

azuñia blanco organic tequila, fresh lime juice, azuñia organic agave nectar

turtles organic blood orange margarita

azuñia blanco organic tequila, thatchers organic blood orange liquor, fresh lime juice, azuñia organic agave nectar

bay breeze

house vodka, pineapple juice and a splash of cranberry juice

siesta sunrise

siesta key coconut rum, pineapple juice and a dash of grenadine

siesta sunset

siesta key spiced rum, oj, pineapple juice and a dash of grenadine

horizons beach ball

coconut rum, pineapple juice, oj, grenadine and dark rum floater

turtles' rum runner

dark rum, light rum, banana and blackberry brandies, pineapple, oj, grenadine and dark rum floater

american mule

tito's vodka, gosling's ginger beer and lime juice

top shelf margarita

patron, cointreau, fresh house made lime juice and a gran gala floater

grasshopper

creme de menthe, crème de cocoa with soft serve ice cream

creamsicle

absolute mandarin vodka, grand marnier, oj with soft serve ice cream

jim beam maple

maple bourbon with soft serve ice cream

piña colada

mango daiquiri | strawberry daiquiri

yellowtail snapper

w/ artichokes, tomatoes & capers

black cod

w/ lobster cream sauce & grilled shrimp

wahoo

w/ avocado, tomato & cilantro

swordfish

w/ kalamata olives, artichokes & capers

tempura fried softshell crab

w/ sweet thai chile glaze

little neck clams

over pasta w/ white wine garlic sauce & red pepper flakes

lobster mac & cheese

w/ mascarpone cheese

lobster tails

one tail

boullabaisse

cobb salad

grilled chicken, bacon, egg, tomatoes, plus avocado w/ crumbled blue cheese over mixed greens

1905 salad

hearts of romaine with green olives, diced tomatoes, ham and swiss cheese, tossed in homemade dressing

bay side salad

fried bay scallops with mandarin oranges, sun-dried cranberries, diced tomatoes, hearts of palm and chunks of mango over field greens with our italian dressing

caesar salad combo

our traditional caesar salad with choice of grilled shrimp or north atlantic salmon

turtle salad

grilled gulf shrimp with mandarin oranges, sun-dried cranberries, diced tomatoes, hearts of palm and chunks of mango over field greens with our italian dressing

cheeseburger in paradise

6 oz. angus beef served with (sharp cheddar cheese), lettuce, tomato, pickle slice and our special sauce.

chicken breast sandwich

6 oz. thick cut breast meat with our buttermilk marinade, served with lettuce, tomato.

classic blt

on sourdough toast

mexican street tacos

choice of tenderloin of beef, gulf fish or chicken breast favorite food in mexico, served on soft tortillas

turkey club

traditional on toasted sourdough bread

north atlantic salmon blt

grilled with a dill sauce

gulf of mexico mahi-mahi

grilled, blackened or fried

open-faced prime rib, 6oz cut, angus beef

served on toast points with au jus

gulf of mexico grouper

grilled, blackened or fried

grouper, pan seared

with white wine and tropical fruit

sesame crusted pan sea

with ginger soy wasabi sauce

baked stuffed shrimp

fresh grilled salmon

topped with cucumber dill sauce, starch and sautéed fresh vegetables

fresh grilled mahi-mahi

with shrimp, sun-dried tomatoes, mushroom, served with starch

seafood pasta

shrimp, scallops, grouper, tomato sauce served over pasta

shrimp scampi

sautéed shrimp, garlic, served over pasta

mussels with pasta

your choice of white

diver scallops

served with starch

almond snapper

encrusted with almond sauce. served with starch

new york strip

hand-cut, served with demi glaze, starch

sautéed chicken

served with a tomato, starch